Research

 

 

 

home

find

overview of standard

overview of resources

overview of research

home

find

standard

resources

research

Drivers rate themselves above average

 

Context

Much research has found that drivers perceive themselves as being better than average. Evans (1991, p. 322) cites Svenson (1981) who had a group of subjects in two countries rank their own safety and driving skill relative to others in the group. Seventy-six percent of the drivers considered themselves as safer than the driver with median safety, and 65% of the drivers considered themselves more skilful than the driver with median skill.

This self-perception can in part be attributed to optimism bias - the finding that most of us have an optimistic perception of our future. Job (1999, p.32) says, 'we see ourselves as less likely than our peers to suffer an early heart attack, have cancer, AIDS or a drinking problem but more likely to live past 80 years, own our home, and have gifted children.' (Weinstein, 1980; 1987; Lee and Job, 1994; Job, 1995). This perception includes seeing ourselves as better than average drivers (Dalzeil and Job, 1994; Job, 1990 and 1990a; Job, Hammer and Walker, 1995; Mathews and Moran, 1986), who are less likely than average to be booked for drink driving (Lee and Job, 1995) or to be injured (or killed) in a car crash (Job, 1990a; Lee et al, 1993).'

You can read a plain English translation of optimism bias and its effects by going to Guard against promoting optimism in An introduction to changing driver behaviour.

Element 3 in Unit 5 has a lesson resource which raises drivers' awareness of this phenomenon and helps them calibrate their perception.

 

 

References

Evans, L. (1991) Traffic safety and the driver, Van Nonstrand Reinhold, New York.

Job, R. F. S. (1999) 'The Road User: The Psychology of Road Safety', Safe and Mobile: Introductory Studies in Traffic Safety, Ed. J. Clark, Emu Press, Armidale,

Links

Drives quickly where appropriate

Guard against promoting optimism

|       copyright       |      DISCLAIMER       |      top of page      |